Quick Answer: Rekey every exterior lock between tenants — every time, without exception. You cannot verify how many copies of the old key exist, and the new tenant deserves a home only they can open. Cover the front, back and garage-entry doors, reset mailbox, keypad and garage codes, collect or retire every old key and fob, and hand over the new keys against a signed log. For multi-unit buildings, a restricted master key system makes the next turnover a one-cylinder job instead of a whole-building one.

Move-out day always ends the same way: a tenant drops two keys on the counter, and the landlord is left to wonder how many more copies exist.

Roommates, partners, cleaners, dog walkers and a spare cut at a kiosk three years ago — none of those copies come back with the lease. Across Maryland, DC and Northern Virginia, the turnover window between tenants is the cheapest, easiest moment to fix that. The unit is empty, there is no scheduling around anyone’s evening, and one visit can reset the whole property. Here is the pass we recommend for landlords in Baltimore, Washington, DC and Alexandria.

Rekey or Replace? The Turnover Rule

Rekeying keeps the existing locks and changes only the pins inside the cylinders, so the old key stops working and a new key takes over. It is the right default when the hardware is sound, matches the property and is a style you want to keep. Replacement makes sense when a lock is worn, damaged, builder-grade, or when you are upgrading — for example to a keypad deadbolt that removes physical spare keys from the equation entirely. Our guide to rekeying vs. changing locks walks through the hardware decision, and the service itself is under Lock Rekeying. What is not an option is leaving the old key working because the departing tenant seemed trustworthy: trust is not the issue, unknown copies are.

Every Door, Not Just the Front

  • Front and back doors — the obvious pair, rekeyed to the new tenant’s key.
  • The garage-entry door — the most-forgotten door in rentals, and often the weakest lock in the building.
  • Basement walk-outs, side doors and deck sliders with keyed locks.
  • Storage units, sheds and gates included in the lease.
  • The mailbox. A locking mailbox still keyed to the old tenant is a privacy problem waiting to happen; rekey or replace it at turnover.

Walk the property with the lease in hand and test every key you were given. A key that opens nothing, or a door no key opens, is a sign something was missed.

Turning over a unit this week? We rekey whole rentals across the DMV in one visit — doors, mailbox and garage entry included — with an upfront quote before work starts. Call (855) 633-2453.

Reset Every Code, Not Just the Keys

Modern turnover is half digital. Clear and re-issue: keypad deadbolt codes (delete every old code, never just add a new one), garage opener remotes and exterior keypads (clear the opener memory, then pair only the new tenant’s remotes), building entry fobs and cards in multi-unit properties, and any smart lock still paired to the old tenant’s phone — factory-reset it and pair it fresh. If the property has a shared laundry, storage or amenity door on a code, that code changes at turnover too when a tenant who knew it has left.

For Multi-Unit Buildings: Think in Systems

One unit is a rekey. Ten units is a key-control problem. A master key system pins each unit’s locks so the tenant’s key opens only their door, while a manager’s master opens every unit for emergencies and maintenance. On restricted keyways, copies can only be cut with your authorization on file — so a tenant cannot duplicate a key at a kiosk and hand it to someone you have never met. At turnover, only that unit’s cylinders are re-pinned; the master keeps working, and the system stays documented. Our master key guide for small businesses explains the levels in plain language, and the same structure fits small apartment buildings, duplexes and mixed-use properties.

The Key Log: Boring, and Worth More Than the Locks

  • Record what was rekeyed and when — unit, doors, date, and the new key’s identifier.
  • Hand over keys against a signature. Note how many keys were issued to the new tenant.
  • Collect everything at move-out — keys, fobs, remotes and cards — and note anything missing; a missing fob in a fobbed building should be deactivated, not just noted.
  • Keep one labelled management copy in a secure place, never in an unlocked leasing-office drawer.

That one-page log is what turns a dispute — “I never got a working key” or “someone still has a copy” — into a record you can point to.

Use the Empty Days Well

Turnover is also the best moment for the small security fixes that are awkward with furniture in the way: strike plates upgraded to long screws into the stud, loose knobs and sagging doors corrected so deadbolts throw fully, and worn weatherstripping replaced so doors latch cleanly. The same checklist mindset we give new homeowners in our move-in lock checklist applies here — the only difference is that you are handing that security over to someone who is trusting you with it.

A new tenant should be able to lock their door on the first night knowing, not hoping, that they hold the only working keys. A turnover rekey is how a landlord makes that true — every unit, every time.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I really need to rekey if the tenant returned all their keys?

Yes. Returned keys prove those copies came back — they say nothing about copies made during the tenancy. Rekeying is the only way to know the old key no longer works, and it is a small, fast job while the unit is empty.

Should every door in the unit share one key?

For a single-family rental or one apartment, keying the exterior doors alike is convenient and common — one key for the tenant, less confusion at move-in. In multi-unit buildings each unit is keyed separately under the building master, so one tenant’s key never opens another unit.

How long does a turnover rekey take?

A typical unit takes under an hour once we are on site, depending on door count and whether mailbox and garage-entry locks are included. Cost depends on cylinder count and hardware condition — current ranges are in our Pricing Guide, and you get an exact upfront quote before any work starts.

Need a Locksmith You Can Trust?

Licensed, insured and on call 24/7 across Maryland, DC & Virginia — with one upfront quote before any work starts.